That sounds like a reasonable plan. I am sure there are people who don't create but are signing up for a card, but the ones that do would more than likely appreciate having more eyes on their works. I've made a rule to not give concrit unless asked, but that is something that can be opted into. I don't know how many people would want to go into the effort of actually doing all this, even if they are willing to put up their own fics. But you're right- it is time consuming and that is time I don't have, at least not right now. I'll chalk it up for round 2 and put a poll out there around August and see what people think.

I might consider just doing a separate post where people can sign-up and leave all their information in the comments and others can peruse it at their own will, and I can just make a list of their threads. Slightly less work than putting together a spreadsheet.